SIHR’s Behind the Boards

The Brooklyn Skating Club's Battle with Professionalism

SIHR’s Behind the Boards

The Brooklyn Skating Club's Battle with Professionalism

John Lokka
Posted May 07, 2019

Viewed 2812 times

    At the start of the 1906-07 winter season, a mid-30s, Stanley Cup champion named Tom “Attie” Howard faced the prospect of being teamless after fifteen years due to a very public row with the Amateur Hockey League. During the 1905-06 season, the New York Amateur Hockey League executive committee barred several players from Howard’s team, the Brooklyn Skating Club, and even warned Tom himself about abusive play (1). In protest, the Brooklyn Skating Club substituted five second string players at their January 6, 1906 game (2). Additionally, Brooklyn Skating Club intentionally played the game undermanned. While the executive committee received protests from both teams, the focus remained on the Tom Howard and the Brooklyn Skating Club (3). A New York Times article indicated the committee considered additional disciplinary measures against Tom, like expulsion, for refusing to play. Within a few days of that protest game, the Brooklyn Skating Club resigned from the league (4) and the team disbanded, which made any judgement a moot point. With more than half of the season remaining, some sportswriters cheered the return of “clean play” equating with Tom’s leaving the game (5). Another consequence of Brooklyn Skating Club’s leaving resulted in Clermont Avenue Rink’s decision against hosting ice skating for the 1906-07 winter (6), which limited hockey games to St. Nicholas rink (7). However, these outcomes play a third line to the larger issues on public parade, which focused on “amateur vs professional”.

Tom Howard
Tom "Attie" Howard

The issues arbitrated during the 1905-06 New York amateur hockey league were a microcosm of the discussions occurring in the larger hockey community. In 1905-06, fame favored the amateur hockeyist.  But, being amateur precluded any compensation of any kind. Amateur players found to be receiving money or even gifts for performance would be disbarred. Even playing against professional teams equated to being considered professional, as Berlin, now Kitchner, discovered (8).  For hockeyists at the time, professional teams lacked stability nor garnered the prestige of the amateur leagues. As a result, allegations and investigations in to professionalism were serious matters. When the Amateur Hockey League’s executive committee decided to charge Tom with “professionalism” (9), Tom faced being locked out of amateur hockey, the associated fame, and his history.

Unfortunately for Tom, Investigative trips to Canada and possibly tensions between owners doomed the Brooklyn Skate Club. The committee’s investigation discovered that hockey players in Ottawa, Montreal and other Canadian cities gossiped about compensation if they signed with the Brooklyn Skating Club (10). Twice before, the Amateur Hockey League investigated Tom on “professionalism” charges. Each time, an owner of an opposing team levied the charge, Brooklyn Skate Club in 1901, (11) and New York Athletic Club in 1903 (12). Each time, the story threads changed from scandal to indignation in the voices for the court of public opinion.  Before the committee rendered final judgement on the third “professionalism” charge, the Brooklyn Skating Club resigned from the league. Regardless, the strongest voices of the court, which included Brooklyn Life, New York Times and others, convicted Tom Howard of all counts of “professionalism”. Tom decided to retire from playing, but he was not done with hockey. For now, amateurism won.


  1. The Evening World (New York, New York) 28 Dec 1905, Thu  • Page 12
  2. The Brooklyn Daily Eagle (Brooklyn, New York) 06 Jan 1906, Sat  • Page 5
  3. The New York Times (New York, New York) 08 Jan 1906, Mon  • Page 7
  4. The Brooklyn Daily Eagle (Brooklyn, New York) 10 Jan 1906, Wed  • Page 11
  5. Brooklyn Life (Brooklyn, New York) 17 Mar 1906, Sat  • Page 22
  6. Evening Star (Washington, District of Columbia) 02 Sep 1906, Sun  • Page 52
  7. The New York Times (New York, New York) 10 Nov 1906, Sat  • Page 10
  8. The Ottawa Journal (Ottawa, Ontario, Canada) 21 Jan 1898, Fri  • Page 6
  9. Brooklyn Life (Brooklyn, New York) 13 Jan 1906, Sat  • Page 38
  10. The New York Times (New York, New York) 03 Jan 1906, Mon  • Page 10
  11. The Brooklyn Daily Eagle (Brooklyn, New York) 1 Mar 1901, Fri • Page 16
  12. The New York Times (New York, New York) 13 Dec 1903, Sun  • Page 16

Viewed 2812 times

Go to top

The Alexander Cup
Posted October 18, 2020

Jimmy Kelly - The man in the lucky black cap
Posted July 21, 2020

SIHR Book Feature on HF Boards
Posted July 12, 2020

Schooley Scandal Plagues Pittsburgh Pucksters
Posted May 09, 2020

A Londoner upsets the Reds - Wembley Lions versus the Soviet Union 1955
Posted April 05, 2020

2020 Online Annual General Meeting Scheduled
Posted March 27, 2020

The Sunday Game that wasn’t
Posted January 14, 2020

A Christmas Free-for-all
Posted December 25, 2019

A Few Minutes with Larry Pleau
Posted November 13, 2019

2019 Fall Meeting in Quebec City Recap
Posted October 22, 2019

The Brooklyn Skating Club's Battle with Professionalism
Posted May 07, 2019

Mystery Player - Solved
Posted December 20, 2018

Celebrating a Half Century of Recognition
Posted July 02, 2018

Team Identification. Can You Help?
Posted June 23, 2018

What's new with the old NHL stats?
Posted April 01, 2018

Unidentified Hockey Team
Posted January 23, 2018

2017 Members Hockey Pool in Support of Road Hockey to Conquer Cancer
Posted September 12, 2017

Silver, Gold and “Ding”
Posted August 19, 2017

Stats Not So Golden for Seals
Posted July 15, 2017

The Inaugural Season
Posted June 15, 2017