Viewed 1478 times
Against All Odds is not just the title of the best-selling book about the gold-medal winning Olympic hockey team from the 1948 Games ... it also describes many of the players we'll see in action at the NHL-less men's hockey tournament at the PyeongChang Games this month.
It's also the title of a documentary from a couple of years back, Against All Odds: The RCAF Flyers.
For those unfamiliar with the story, a brief summary: The Olympics return after the Second World War, based in the resort town of St. Moritz, Switzerland for the 1948 Games; after much deliberation, Canada agrees to a team made up primarily of Royal Canadian Air Force personnel; no one knows what to expect from the team, or the hockey competition in general, due to the war (and the Soviet Union had not yet set up shop atop the medal podium); Canada wins gold; the individual stories of the players, how they survived the perils of war, are more compelling than the games themselves.
The man behind both the 2015 documentary and the book, Against All Odds. The Untold Story of Canada's Unlikely Hockey Heroes, which came out in late 2017, is P.J. Naworynski, of Hyperfocal Films (http://www.hyperfocalfilms.com). Naworynski is a Gemini award-winning documentary filmmaker with 20 years of experience under his belt.
Making the film, Against All Odds, was old hat to Naworynski; creating a book was not.
“Making a documentary and writing a book are two very different beasts. Despite the fact that I’d written and directed dozens and dozens of documentaries for international broadcast, I had no idea how much more time consuming the writing process for a book would be,” explained Naworynski. “I assumed writing 80,000 plus words for print would take me a few months of extra research and about four to five months of writing time. But it took me significantly longer for a myriad of reasons.”
He laid out those issues: “Finding the voice, writing each and every day. Just conditioning myself to being more descriptive and colouring the scenes versus TV writing, which is directed toward letting the pictures speak for themselves. Once I got in the groove though, I really enjoyed the experience. With the book I could go into much greater depth and detail. I could expand on tangents of the storyline and the characters that a limited TV run never allows.”
Naworynski quickly dispels any notion that he's a hockey expert or an obsessive over the Olympic Games. “I had no idea about the story when I first was approached to write and direct the documentary. My grandfather was in the RCAF and I knew the boys played hockey and baseball and football and such but I had zero clue about the Flyers and their run for gold in the ’48 Olympics. Truly, I was amazed almost every day.”
There are plenty of astounding stories. Hockey-wise, notables include goaltender Murray Dowey showcasing one of the first trapper gloves and dazzling with an incredible 0.63 goals against average in the eight games, giving up just five goals, and Wally Halder's 21 goals during the tournament. Yet none of the players ever made it to the NHL.
The hockey stories are there in the book, but it's the personal stories that will resonate, and Naworynski said it was “a conscious decision not to overload the book with too much war.” Hubie Brooks could probably have been a movie or book on his own. His plane was shot down, and from April 1942 to May 1943 he was a prisoner of war in a German camp, escaping on his third try. He joined the Polish underground and continued to fight. For his efforts, he was awarded the Military Cross (one of only five RCAF officers), the Polish Silver Cross of Merit with Swords, and the Polish Cross of Valor. He ended up as a substitute at the Games though.
Another gem is Patsy Guzzo's diary/journal. “Patsy’s journal was a great resource for me. It was almost like having the chance to interview him myself,” Naworynski said of the left winger who died in 1993. “His entries are personal and colourful and heartfelt. It was a wonderful, generous contribution to help add to the book. It informed not only Patsy’s journey and story but the greater story of the team and some of the guys.” (For example, it was Guzzo's first train ride.)
The circumstances are remarkable to Naworynski as well. “The physical conditions they played in at the Olympics... the snowballs being pelted at them... riding the bus in full gear... the idea that our Olympic hockey team was eating that rancid food at the Crofton,” were some of the issues that stand out.
The result of all the work is a book that is rich in details. “The personal diaries and interviews with family members were really the key for me,” said Naworynski, continuing. “Primary research, as close to the actual source as possible. If not interviews, then diaries, writings, journals, official military records. From the outset, I knew that sources of information that are off the beaten path weren’t really going to be a big contributor for me. I did turn to the period newspaper articles and weather data and official IOC documents to help flesh areas out. But I felt this book had to be built on primary research. It’s a personal story, that’s how I wanted to tell it.”
As compelling and fascinating as some of the stories were – Roy Forbes is another like Brooks whose war stories are page-turning – Naworynski knew it was a team game, and did his best to reflect that. While those four or five key figures get significant ink, “I also wanted to weave in bits from the other guys as best I could and also play with the larger story of the team, the country and the pulse of our nation.”
For the record, this is actually the second book about the 1948 RCAF Flyers. Pat MacAdam's 2008 effort, Gold Medal 'Misfits' (Manor House Publishing) has interviews with some of the players who are no longer around.
His documentary aided in the sell to HarperCollins, said Naworynski. He knew Brad Wilson at the publishing house and they started talking about the project.
“ I always felt the lives of these guys and what they accomplished in war and in peace could inspire Canadians like me who knew nothing about them. Brad agreed and we talked about the book and what stories I could flesh out and focus on, what additional research I needed to acquire and who would be involved and we were off to the races,” said Naworynski. “They wanted to key in on the title from the documentary and the producer of the doc liked that I’d be using a similar title to the documentary as well since Sportsnet still airs the doc on Remembrance Day.”
In short, with the documentary, two books, and many honours, the RCAF Flyers have not been overlooked any longer.
“I can’t believe they were essentially forgotten after accomplishing what no one thought was possible,” concluded Naworynski. “I was astounded that it took so long for them to be inducted into Canada’s Sports Hall of Fame... 60 years! That’s nuts to me.”
MORE CANADIAN OLYMPIC READING
Working on my book, Father Bauer and the Great Experiment, I became a little bit of an expert on the various Canadian Olympic hockey-related books that are out there. By far the one that is the most “fun” is Hometown Heroes: On the Road with Canada's National Hockey Team, written by the late, great Paul Quarrington; it's his adventures with the 1988 Canadian team, and, like Quarrington's novels, it ranges from hilarious to poignant.
Two of the pillars of Canadian sports journalism, Scott Young and Jim Coleman, have done books on international hockey—War On Ice: Canada in International Hockey (1976) and Hockey is our Game: Canada in the World of International Hockey (1967) respectively.
Brian Conacher's two books both touch on his Olympic experiences, with 1970's Hockey in Canada: The Way Is It! rocking the establishment, and 2007's As the Puck Turns: A Personal Journey Through the World of Hockey being much more broad-reaching.
There are lots of photo books and books aimed at younger children too, especially for more recent gold-medal winning Canadian teams, women's and men's teams alike. The story of the 2002 gold-medal winning Canadian team, after a 50-year drought, is best collected in Roy MacGregor's A Loonie for Luck.
Andrew Podnieks figures into a lot of international hockey books, including IIHF Top 100 Hockey Stories of All-time (with Szymon Szemberg, 2008), and Canada's Olympic Hockey History, 1920 – 2010, Canada's Olympic Hockey Teams , 1920 – 1998.
Us hockey-heads will be tuning in at some odd hours to see who claims hockey gold this go-round.
Viewed 1478 times
CBC Radio's Jeremy Allingham explores 'Human Cost of Fighting'
Posted September 03, 2019
Victoria hockey book a long time coming
Posted August 19, 2019
Beers and books with Goldie and Liam
Posted June 14, 2019
Book on Kansas City Scouts a real Treasure
Posted May 28, 2019
Exploring Seattle's rich hockey history
Posted May 13, 2019
The unappreciated Lionel Hitchman and George Orton
Posted April 29, 2019
Addicted to Hockey, in Any Format
Posted April 13, 2019
The Stanley Cup and Kate's hockey greatness
Posted April 01, 2019
Writing and illustrating about hockey for developing readers
Posted March 17, 2019
Johnston and Walter re-team with more Plays and Strategies
Posted March 03, 2019
More Orr and Rangers via self-published books
Posted February 18, 2019
The overachieving 1978-79 Rangers get their due
Posted February 06, 2019
Commito delivers a year's worth of hockey stories
Posted January 16, 2019
Ending the year with the bestselling Kirstie McLellan Day
Posted December 30, 2018
Feel Good Book of the Year
Posted December 16, 2018
New Oilers book will have fans gushing
Posted December 05, 2018
Legend of Johnny Bower lives on
Posted November 20, 2018
Baruchel puts his love of hockey onto the page
Posted November 06, 2018
Going Back to 1993 Again
Posted October 24, 2018
Down Goes Brown found time for a book
Posted October 09, 2018
Getting to know Bob Chrystal
Posted September 25, 2018
Five S's: Steven Sandor's Sports Stories showcased
Posted September 12, 2018
Let's hear from the moms
Posted August 29, 2018
Good as Goldham
Posted July 19, 2018
Keeping the WHA memory alive
Posted July 03, 2018
The Price is right
Posted June 19, 2018
Take off with the Flying Fathers
Posted June 06, 2018
Considering those general managers
Posted May 24, 2018
The Russian Five come alive in print and film
Posted May 11, 2018
The 'number' of Rangers books grows
Posted April 25, 2018
MacGregors deliver hockey magic
Posted April 13, 2018
When it's not just a hockey book
Posted March 20, 2018
Posted March 08, 2018
Denis Gibbons, international man of hockey
Posted February 21, 2018
From Manitoba to Latvia
Posted January 23, 2018
Listen up, it's a Hull of a story
Posted January 10, 2018
What a century/year it's been
Posted December 27, 2017
Won't Somebody Think of the Children
Posted December 12, 2017
A Hat Trick of Self-Published Gems
Posted November 30, 2017
Resurrecting the California Golden Seals
Posted November 13, 2017
Dryden Returns to Action
Posted November 01, 2017
Maruk's Highs and Lows
Posted October 19, 2017
Father Knows Best(seller?)
Posted October 03, 2017
Deep in the Heart of Texas
Posted September 21, 2017
The Cat and his Rangers
Posted September 04, 2017
Bien sûr, c'est bien plus que les Canadiens
Posted August 22, 2017
The Sound and the Fury in Hockey Audiobooks
Posted August 09, 2017
Zweig Busy, Marshall almost Ready and Denault on the Mend
Posted July 20, 2017
Stocking the Shelf
Posted July 09, 2017